• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • About
  • Press Room
  • Poverty & Race Journal
  • Donate
  • Publications
    • PRRAC Publications & PRRAC Authors
    • PRRAC Policy Briefs
    • PRRAC Advocacy Resources
    • PRRAC Advocacy Letters
  • Events
  • Contact

PRRAC — Connecting Research to Advocacy

Poverty & Race Research Action Council

MENUMENU
  • Fair Housing
    • Fair Housing Homepage
    • Federal Housing Advocacy – by Program
    • Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH)
    • Housing Mobility (Section 8)
    • Source of Income Discrimination
    • Low Income Housing Tax Credit
    • Fair Housing and Community Development
    • Civil Rights and Housing Finance Reform
  • School Diversity
  • Environmental Justice
  • Special Projects
    • Civil Rights History
    • Civil Rights & The Administrative State
    • Expanding the "Social Housing" Sector
    • Housing-School Nexus
    • International Human Rights and U.S. Civil Rights Policy
    • One Nation Indivisible: School Diversity, Immigrant Integration, and Multi-Racial Coalitions
    • PRRAC in the Courts
    • Alliance Housing Justice
  • Search
    • Search

You are here: Home / Browse PRRAC Content / Poverty & Race Journal / “The Urgent Public Health Need to Extend Eviction Moratoria and Mortgage Forbearance Programs” by Gregory D. Squires and Ira Goldstein (Sept/Oct 2020 P&R Issue)

“The Urgent Public Health Need to Extend Eviction Moratoria and Mortgage Forbearance Programs” by Gregory D. Squires and Ira Goldstein (Sept/Oct 2020 P&R Issue)

October 31, 2020 by

By Gregory D. Squires and Ira Goldstein (Click here to view the entire PDF)

The latest Census Household Pulse Survey (October 14–26, 2020) reveals that 1.1 million rental households (13.1%) and 395 thousand owners (4.6%) feel that it is very likely that they will lose their home in the next two months due to foreclosure or eviction. An estimated 3.6 million owner households and 5.5 million renter households have “no confidence” that they will be able to pay their next month’s mortgage or rent. No doubt these fears reflect a widespread understanding of some of the costs, economic and others, of the coronavirus pandemic. Not so widely understood is how the pandemic is, in part, a result of evictions and foreclosures. In other words, the causal arrow goes both ways. The pandemic leads to the loss of homes, but the loss of homes also contributes to the pandemic.

Pandemic related evictions are not just a hypothetical problem. Prince­ton’s Eviction Lab estimates that more than 105 thousand households in just 25 cities, some of which had eviction moratoria in place, were subject to evictions since March. At the very same time as the number of COVID-19 cases and hospitalizations are on the rise, many federal, state, and local benefits and protections against eviction are expiring. It is worthy of note that owing to the rise in COVID-19 cases and persistent advocacy, a local Philadelphia court order stays most “lock outs” until December 31, 2020.

As has widely been reported by The COVID Racial Data Tracker and many other sources, people of color are disproportionately affected.  Philadelphia is a case in point. Philadelphia’s COVID-19 test positivity rate has been on the rise for the last two months and the city’s Department of Public Health considers the city in a period of “high risk of community transmission.” In plain language, this means that people are getting sick and trackers cannot even figure out how they got sick. It is worth reminding that while the pandemic has not been good for anyone, racially, Philadelphians have experienced the pandemic very differently. Black and Hispanic Philadelphians have a test positivity rate that is 1.7 times greater than that of Whites. The Black and Hispanic hospitalization rates are 2.6 and 2.0 times that of Whites, respectively. And the Black death rate is 1.4 times that of Whites.

How can we understand these differences? The CDC suggests that housing, in part due to over-crowding and in another part due to racial differences in incomes and job stability, is a contributor to observed racial disparities in COVID-19.

Mortgage foreclosures and evictions in Philadelphia undoubtedly contribute to Philadelphia’s COVID-19 problem as well as the racial disparities plaguing the city. Reinvestment Fund tracks eviction filings in Philadelphia dating back to 2010. Eviction filings peaked in 2011/2012 at around 22 thousand and trended down to 18,141 thousand in 2018, then rose to 18,330 in 2019. Like the COVID-19 data though, these overall rates mask substantial household and neighborhood differences. The Black non-Hispanic eviction rate in 2018/2019 is estimated to be 9.0% compared to 6.5% for Hispanics and 2.6% for White non-Hispanic renters.

Rising unemployment contributed to these housing downturns. Phil­adelphia’s number of unemployed rose from 43.6 thousand from February of this year to 85.3 thousand in September and the unemployment rate over that period rose from 5.9 to 11.7 (preliminary estimate for September), off the peak pandemic rate exceeding 18%.

It is within this economic upheaval that eviction moratoria may well be lifted in the not-too-distant future. Landlords (large or small) cannot serve as the social safety net that historically has been the purview of government. But that doesn’t change the fact that people who are subject to an eviction are likely to end up in households with more people, because of doubling up or a stay in the city’s shelter system or an encampment, and are therefore more likely to encounter other people who are infected. And if they are themselves infected, they will spread the virus to others. A University of Pennsylvania epidemiologist declared that resuming evictions would lead to a significant and substantial number of excess COVID-19 infections.

For many years, several local, national, and even international organizations have advanced the notion that stable housing must be a right, not a privilege. The United Nations, the Right to the City Alliance, among others assert that in addressing the many challenges facing the homeless stable housing is a prerequisite to stable employment, educational achievement, and in this moment, staying safe when there is a deadly virus moving through a community.

When families engage in the legal process of an eviction or foreclosure, they often deal with and encounter lawyers, courts, movers, well-meaning neighbors and others, often including the friends and families with whom they double up. One unintended, though clear, consequence is the increased likelihood of catching and spreading the COVID-19 infection. This is not a time to end renter financial supports, eviction moratoria or mortgage forbearance programs. Keeping people in their homes is a critical component of an effective public health response to the pandemic.

Gregory D. Squires (squires@gwu.edu) is a Professor of Sociology & Public Policy & Public Administration, George Washington University. Ira Goldstein (Ira.Goldstein@ reinvestment.com) is President of Policy Solutions, Reinvestment Fund.

Filed Under: Fair Housing, Poverty & Race Journal

You might also like…

“A New Vision for Fair Housing in the Real Estate Industry – Part 1: How the Housing Search Process Perpetuates Segregation” by Maria Krysan & Allison K. Bethel (May – Sept 2021 P&R Issue)
“A New Vision for Fair Housing in the Real Estate Industry – Part II: An Actionable Fair Housing Strategy for Real Estate Agents & Agencies” by Allison K. Bethel & Maria Krysan (May – Sept 2021 P&R Issue)

Primary Sidebar

PRRAC Updates

PRRAC Update (July 28, 2022): Raising Voucher Rents; Upcoming CERD Review

PRRAC Update (June 17, 2022): mobility funding campaign – and AFFH goes to OMB!

PRRAC Update (June 2, 2022): School Diversity Funding Campaign; PHAs and School Districts

Previous Updates...

PRRAC in the News

Why the Latest Fight About Charter Rules Matters — for Schools and Education Politics (Chalkbeat)

May 9, 2022

Democrats Have No Plan to Fight Housing Inflation (Vox)

November 11, 2021

‘We Don’t Take That:’ Why Illegal Discrimination Toward Section 8 Tenants Goes Unchecked in NJ (Asbury Park Press)

October 26, 2021

Undoing Structural Racism: The Need for Systemic Change in Housing Policy (Nonprofit Quarterly)

August 4, 2021

Previous Posts...

PRRAC on Twitter

Tweets by @PRRAC_DC

Poverty & Race Journal

Footer

PRRAC – Poverty & Race Research Action Council

The Poverty & Race Research Action Council (PRRAC) is a civil rights law and policy organization based in Washington, D.C. Our mission is to promote research-based advocacy strategies to address structural inequality and disrupt the systems that disadvantage low-income people of color. PRRAC was founded in 1989, through an initiative of major civil rights, civil liberties, and anti-poverty groups seeking to connect advocates with social scientists working at the intersection of race and poverty…Read More

Archives

Resources at PRRAC

  • Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing
  • Environmental Justice
  • Fair Housing
  • Fair Housing & Community Development
  • Low Income Housing Tax Credit
  • Poverty & Race Journal
  • PRRAC Update
  • School Diversity
  • Housing Choice Voucher Mobility
  • PRRAC in The Courts

Copyright © 2022 · Magazine Pro on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in var _ctct_m = "7608c7e98e90af7d6ba8b5fd4d901424"; //static.ctctcdn.com/js/signup-form-widget/current/signup-form-widget.min.js

PRRAC — Connecting Research to Advocacy

  • Fair Housing
    • Fair Housing Homepage
    • Federal Housing Advocacy – by Program
    • Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH)
    • Housing Mobility (Section 8)
    • Source of Income Discrimination
    • Low Income Housing Tax Credit
    • Fair Housing and Community Development
    • Civil Rights and Housing Finance Reform
  • School Diversity
  • Environmental Justice
  • Special Projects
    • Civil Rights History
    • Civil Rights & The Administrative State
    • Expanding the “Social Housing” Sector
    • Housing-School Nexus
    • International Human Rights and U.S. Civil Rights Policy
    • One Nation Indivisible: School Diversity, Immigrant Integration, and Multi-Racial Coalitions
    • PRRAC in the Courts
    • Alliance Housing Justice
  • Search
  • About
  • Press Room
  • Poverty & Race Journal
  • Donate
  • Publications
    • PRRAC Publications & PRRAC Authors
    • PRRAC Policy Briefs
    • PRRAC Advocacy Resources
    • PRRAC Advocacy Letters
  • Events
  • Contact